How To Break In A Softball Glove

Do you have a new softball glove that needs to be broken in? Breaking in your glove is an important part of the game, so you want to make sure it’s done properly. It’s also an enjoyable part of prepping for the season and can even become a tradition for your team. If you don’t know how to break in a softball glove, don’t worry! We’ve got you covered. In this article, we will explain the steps needed to break in a softball glove quickly and effectively.

Breaking in your glove doesn’t have to be intimidating or difficult. With just a few simple steps, you can get your glove ready for the upcoming season with ease. Read on to learn more about breaking in a softball glove and what tools you need in order to do it successfully. From forming the pocket correctly to conditioning it with oil, we’ll give you all of the information that you need to break in your new glove like a pro!

If you love playing softball and want to make sure that your game is at its best, then read on. We will teach you how to break in your softball glove so that it fits perfectly and lasts through the entire season!

Reasons To Break In A Softball Glove

Is it true that breaking in a softball glove is necessary? Absolutely! Softball gloves are designed with a stiff leather, so they won’t form to your hand until you break them in. Breaking in a softball glove gives it the perfect shape and feel for your particular hand size and playing style.

Breaking in a glove also increases its durability and longevity. It’s much more likely to last through multiple games if you take the time to break it in properly. You’ll find that after breaking in a softball glove, your fielding performance will improve as well. You’ll be able to make quicker catches with less effort, giving you an advantage over other players who haven’t broken their gloves in correctly.

Now that we’ve established why breaking in a softball glove is important, let’s move on to selecting the right one for you.

Selecting The Right Softball Glove

Selecting the right softball glove is like finding a key that fits the lock of your dreams. It’s essential to choose a glove that fits your hand comfortably and has the right amount of padding. Finding the perfect glove can be like searching for a needle in the haystack, but with some research, you’ll be able to find one that meets your needs.

When selecting a softball glove, consider what type of position you play on the field. If you’re an outfielder, you need more padding because there’s a chance hardballs will come flying at you; an infielder requires less padding since these catches often involve softer throws. The length of the glove should also be based on your position—an infielder usually needs something shorter and narrower than an outfielder does.

It’s also important to try several gloves before making a purchase decision—they may look similar but they all fit differently. Go to stores with experts who can give helpful advice and help you find the right size and shape for your position and preferences. With their assistance, you’ll soon have a trusty companion in your new softball mitt!

Prepping The Glove

Breaking in a softball glove is an almost magical process. It’s a combination of science, art, and lots of patience. Prepping the glove for success requires time and effort – but when done right, it can truly transform your game!

The first step to prepping your softball glove is to soften it up. You may think you can just dive into using it and the leather will bend to your will – but that’s simply not true! Instead, you’ll need to use some special ingredients to do the trick. Start by rubbing some shaving cream along the surface of the glove and then work it in with a damp cloth or paper towel. Doing this will help break down any stiffness in the leather, making it much more pliable for your needs.

Next up is conditioning the leather. This is an important step as it helps keep your glove looking great while also protecting it from wear and tear over time. You should apply a leather conditioner or mink oil all over the surface of the glove and then buff away any excess with a clean cloth. Doing this regularly will ensure that your glove remains flexible and ready for action no matter how much you use it!

Now you’re ready to get started on packing your glove – an essential part of breaking in a softball glove correctly.

Packing The Glove

It is a widely held belief that packing a softball glove will break it in faster. But is there any truth to this theory? Recent studies suggest that the process of packing a glove may help accelerate the breaking-in process, but it is only one step in the overall approach. Here are some tips for packing your glove:

• Place a baseball or softball in the pocket area and tightly wrap rubber bands around it to create tension in the leather. • Use a balled up towel to stuff inside the fingers of the glove. This helps shape them so they can fit your hand better when you use them • Place an old sock or rag into the palm area and wrap more rubber bands around it. This helps form the pocket and shape of your glove.

These steps should be done with care, as too much force applied while wrapping can damage the leather of your glove. Additionally, don’t forget to pay attention to all parts of your glove – from the fingertips down to the heel – or else you may find yourself with an unevenly shaped pocket or misshapen fingers. It’s important to take time during this process and ensure each part of your glove has been evenly packed and tensioned before moving on to oiling it up for optimal performance. With patience and attention to detail, packing your softball glove will help ensure you have a comfortable fit when playing ball.

Oiling The Glove

After packing the glove with a softball, the next step is to oil it. Oiling a new glove helps the leather become supple and mold to your hand. Taking the time to oil a glove will make breaking it in easier and keep it in better condition for longer.

To oil the glove, apply a leather conditioner or light weight oil evenly across the entire surface of the glove. Work the oil into the creases and seams using your fingers as much as possible before buffing out any excess with a cloth or towel. A little bit of oil goes a long way – you don’t want to over-oil your glove, which can make it stiff and reduce its lifespan.

Once you’ve applied enough oil, let it sit overnight so that it can soak in deeply. This will ensure that all of the leather has been properly conditioned and will help break in your glove much faster than if you skip this step. And now that you’ve finished prepping your glove, it’s time to move onto stretching it out for use.

Stretching The Glove

Breaking in a glove is like taming a wild horse – it takes time, patience, and the right techniques to get the job done. After oiling up the glove to soften it, stretching it out is the next step to make sure your glove fits you like a glove.

To stretch out your glove, start by fastening two or three fingers of your non-dominant hand into each of the finger stalls on either side of the pocket. Using your dominant hand, firmly pull back on one of these fingers while keeping pressure on with your non-dominant hand. You should feel as if you are lengthening and widening the leather in that area. Do this for each finger stall until you can comfortably fit all four fingers into the pocket of your glove without needing to use extra force.

Repeat this process around the thumb and pinky stalls as well as along any other areas that seem too tight or small for a comfortable fit. With a bit of time and effort, you’ll be able to adjust and customize your glove so that it fits just right before moving onto the next step: using a mallet to break in the leather even further.

Using A Mallet To Break In The Glove

Breaking in a softball glove can be tricky. Once you have stretched it out, the next step is to use a mallet to break in the glove even more. A mallet is a tool that’s used to help shape and mold an item. It’s important to make sure you’re using the right size mallet for the glove. Too small of a mallet won’t do enough work and too large could cause damage.

Start by working on one side of the glove at a time, hitting the pocket area with the mallet. You want to hit it firmly but not too hard as this could cause damage or break down the fibers of the glove. You should also make sure you are using something like an old pillowcase or towel between your hand and the mallet so that it doesn’t slip and cause injury. Once you’ve done one side, flip it over and repeat on the other side.

After you’ve hit each side with a few good strikes from your mallet, you should see some difference in how much easier it is to get your hand into the pocket area of your glove. To ensure that it is broken in properly, continue this process until your hand slides easily into place without any resistance or struggle when putting on your glove. With proper use of a mallet, you can quickly break in your new softball glove so it’s ready for game time!

Bending The Glove

The last step in breaking in your softball glove is to bend it. Like a river, the leather will slowly start to take shape if you guide it. As with the other steps, use some elbow grease and the glove will be ready before you know it!

Starting with the palm of the glove, fold it back onto itself and press down hard. Use your body weight to really get into it; not only will this help break in the glove faster, but it’ll also help make sure any irregularities are eliminated. Move around the edges of the glove as well, forcing them into place so they don’t come undone during play.

Finally, when everything is shaped correctly and all that’s left is to tie up loose ends, make sure that you punch out any wrinkles or excess leather. This will ensure that your glove fits like a dream once game time starts! With a little effort and patience, your glove will be ready for its inaugural season on the diamond.

Tying The Glove

The last step in breaking in a softball glove is tying the glove. This will help to ensure that the glove holds its shape and keeps its structure. Because of this, it’s important to tie the glove properly.

To start, you’ll need a few items: laces, a mallet or hammer, and something to protect the glove while you’re tying it. Here are five steps for how to tie your softball glove:

  1. Start by threading the lace through both of the thumb loops on your new glove.
  2. Then, pull each side tight and tie them together at the bottom of the thumb loops.
  3. Take one of your laces and thread it through both index finger holes on your new glove.
  4. Pull each side tight and then use a mallet or hammer to flatten out any bumps in the webbing between your fingers and thumb.
  5. Finally, wrap each lace around your wrist four times so that it fits snugly against your hand.

By following these steps, you can ensure that your softball glove fits perfectly with minimal effort. After tying up your glove, it’s time to break in the webbing between the thumb and fingers which will give us more flexibility when we play ball.

Breaking In The Webbing

The 10th step in breaking in a softball glove is breaking in the webbing. This is an important step to ensure that your glove not only fits comfortably and securely on your hand, but that it also provides maximum protection from errant balls. To break in the webbing, there are four main steps to follow:

First, use a softball or a similar object and place it in the pocket of the glove. Then, close the glove around the object so that it is fully secured within the pocket. Next, firmly squeeze and rub the pocket with both hands for a few minutes. Finally, open and close the pocket several times to further loosen up any tough material.

By doing these four steps, you will be able to make sure that your glove’s webbing is properly broken in and ready for play. It’s important to note that this process should be repeated with each new glove you purchase as well as every season for existing gloves. Doing so will help to maintain its shape and comfort level throughout its lifetime.

With proper breaking-in techniques employed, your glove will be ready for action – now all that’s left is taking care of it following each game or practice session.

Taking Care Of The Glove After Breaking-In

Once the webbing has been broken in, there’s one more step to take: taking care of the glove. Properly conditioning and maintaining the glove is essential in keeping it soft and pliable. This begins with removing any dirt or debris from the glove on a regular basis. To do this, use a soft brush or cloth to wipe away any particles.

Next, apply a thin layer of leather conditioner to the exterior of the glove. This will help keep it hydrated and prevent cracks from forming. Be sure to avoid using too much as it can damage the material. Finally, store the glove properly when not in use; preferably somewhere cool and dry like an equipment bag or closet shelf.

By following these steps and regularly caring for your glove, you can ensure that it remains soft and pliable for years to come. Transitioning into alternatives, some players opt not to break in their gloves at all but rather purchase them pre-broken in from the manufacturer or opt for alternative materials such as synthetic leathers that don’t require breaking in.

Alternatives To Breaking In The Glove

Breaking in a softball glove can feel like an insurmountable challenge, especially if you’re not sure where to start. But don’t worry, with the right tools and techniques, you’ll have your glove broken-in in no time! With that said, let’s take a look at some alternatives to breaking in the glove.

For starters, there are oil treatments that you can apply to the leather to make it more pliable. These treatments help loosen up the fibers in the leather so it’s easier to break in over time. It’s also important to note that these oil treatments should only be applied once a week for optimal results.

Another alternative is to use a glove mallet or other similar tool to break-in your glove quickly and easily. This method helps shape the pocket of the glove while making sure it retains its original shape and size. However, this method should only be used as a last resort since it can damage the leather if done incorrectly. TIP: Before attempting any of these methods, make sure you read through all of the instructions carefully so that you don’t end up damaging your glove instead of breaking it in!

Common Mistakes To Avoid

Having gone through the alternatives to breaking in a softball glove, now it’s time to look at some common mistakes to avoid. The first mistake is failing to condition the glove with oil. It’s essential to keep the leather of your glove soft and supple by regularly conditioning it with an oil specifically designed for conditioning leather. Additionally, don’t over-tighten lacing or straps on your glove when trying to break it in. This can actually damage the leather and cause it to crack or tear prematurely. Lastly, don’t try and break in your glove too quickly. Allowing more time for the leather of your glove to soften gradually will produce better results and help prevent any damage from occurring.

Ultimately, if you want a comfortable and flexible glove that’ll last you for years, it’s important not to make these mistakes when breaking it in. Taking the time to properly break in your glove will ensure you have a quality piece of equipment that will perform well on the field season after season.

Now that we’ve covered some basic tips for avoiding common mistakes when breaking in a softball glove, let’s move onto what steps you should take for proper conditioning…

Tips For Breaking In The Glove

Navigating the terrain of breaking in a softball glove can be a tricky journey. It’s essential to keep an open mind and be willing to explore new methods when establishing a successful outcome. As you embark on your venture, here are some tips for breaking in the glove that should help you make it to the final destination.

To start, it’s important to remember that patience is key. Breaking in a new glove takes time and effort, so don’t expect results overnight. Take your time applying oil or conditioner and massaging it into the leather – this will ensure that the glove molds to your hand properly while providing better comfort and control over time. To speed up the process, you can use a softball or tennis ball as a tool; insert it into the pocket of the glove and hold closed with one hand while forming its shape with your other hand.

Furthermore, don’t forget to apply some common sense when breaking in your glove. While some people recommend using heat or microwaving your glove for faster results, this could potentially do more harm than good by weakening the material – which isn’t ideal if you’re looking for durability. Choosing quality materials from reliable sources is also crucial; investing in higher quality gloves made from genuine leather will result in less maintenance and longer lifespan compared to synthetic alternatives.

With these tips in mind, you should now be armed with the knowledge necessary to break-in your softball glove effectively without any issues – leaving only troubleshooting left on this journey!

Troubleshooting Glove-Breaking-In Issues

Breaking in a softball glove can be tricky business. Like taming a wild beast, it takes patience and tenacity to get the job done. However, with these simple tips and tricks, you’ll be well on your way to having the softest and most comfortable glove around.

Troubleshooting glove-breaking-in issues is key to making sure your mitt is ready to take on every pitch that comes its way. There are two main categories of potential problems: fit and feel.

For fit issues, check your glove size and make sure that it fits your hand comfortably when you wear it. If you have trouble closing the pocket when the ball is in there, try stretching the pocket out by placing a softball in it and tying it closed with some string or laces overnight.

In terms of feel, adding some oil or lanolin can help soften up the leather so that it has just the right amount of give for that perfect scooping action. Additionally, repetitively flexing and bending the glove will also help break it in more quickly as well as reinforce its shape over time.

No matter what troubleshooting method you use, remember to take your time and be gentle with your glove – eventually all its hard work will pay off!


Conclusion: Breaking in a softball glove is an important part of the game. It can give you the confidence and comfort to make the plays that win games. The process of breaking in a glove may seem tedious and time consuming, but it can pay dividends down the line. Like a relationship, when you invest time into breaking in your glove, it will reward you with its loyalty on the field. As long as you follow these steps and use some patience, your glove will be ready for any play or catch you throw at it. So take the time to break in your glove, treat it right, and let it be your trusty companion on the diamond.